Fri Aug 27, 2010 7:03 am by Aateeters
I believe any English only policy is clearly racist, even though the racists enforcing the policy don't realize it.
Some say that English speakers are uncomfortable when they don't understand the chat in other languages. This argument is so insensitive that it makes me angry. Why don't you care about how uncomfortable it is for someone to be told, "Hey, your language isn't welcome here." This is such an obvious point that I have no sympathy for those who didn't think of it themselves.
The presence of non-English doesn't prevent English speakers from chatting. But muting people chatting in a foreign language definitely does. Furthermore, I think the vast majority of people don't care if there is some chat they don't understand. I think the English-only people are inventing this concern.
Also, some say that since the game is in English, everyone here can speak English. I'm an English teacher at a Korean school. I can tell you what happens to a discussion amongst students when you force them to speak a second language: it goes from raucus to absolutely dead.
When you ban other languages out of concern for the "comfort level" of English speakers, you are basically saying that silencing all non-English speakers is not a problem for you. And that is racist.
Finally, the swearing issue. Some blacks steal things. But we don't allow store owners to exclude all blacks. Some people swear in foreign languages, but far more people swear by using **** and s pace s in their words. Banning all foreign language is a draconian response. It says that we would rather alienate all non-English speakers than possibly allow one one-hundredth of the swearing that goes on in English.
Thinks about two issues:
1 Does it really bother you to see a foreign language?
2 Who is more likely to withdraw from chat, an English speaker who sees a few lines of a foreign language, or a non-English speaker who is threatened for using their native language?
3 Are there less discriminatory ways of moderating non-English?
Sorry that was so long. Serious replies appreciated.