Prestige for Retreating

Haypi really needs to look at Calculating Prestiege when someone recalls their troops mid-fight.
How are you expected to move up the ranks when you are clearly winning a fight and the other person retreats their attack from you before it's over and you get nothing from it?

Here's how I think it should work:
Callback of Troops BEFORE a fight - 2 Coins
Callback of Troops DURING a fight - 4 Coins, loss of 25% of the prestiege of the retreating troops, AND normal prestiege calculations for the battle.

For example, assuming Prestiege award levels of 1/inf, 4/Cav, 2/Arch, 10/Cat
Attacker and Defender each have 500/250/250/1000

Defender kills all Attacker's Cats but losses 500 of their own.
Attacker Retreats
Retreating Army is 500/250/250/0
Defender Army Remaining is 500/250/250/750
The value of the Retreating Army is 2000 Prestiege
The Value of the Troops the Defender Killed is 10,000
The Value of the Troops the Attacker Killed is 5,000

Therefore, when the Attacker Retreats, the Attacker should Lose the normal 5,000 PLUS 25% of the 2000, or 500 for a total of 5,500 Prestiege gained.
The Defender would only gain the prestiege from the units that were killed.

Even if they don't implement the Penalty, Troops Killed should always equal prestiege, Period.

Although you lose the prestige from units you lost gotta add that in

Retreating has a Penalty. I vote no if you're saying attacker should gain prestige when he retreats.

I dont think u should be able to retreat if u attacked your fault although callback shoujld be allowed

from the way you have put this, it looks like he took out some of your troops then he retreated, nothing wrong with gaining some free prestige its how the game is played, build your turrents up to 10, and keep good strong defense so next time he wont touch you =)

I disagree - it should not cost you prestige to withdraw from a battle you are losing (since that's one reason to withdraw in the first place...) but a scaled amount of coins.

It shouldn't cost 5 coins to withdraw 10 men, and still 5 coins to withdraw 10,000

Maybe the penalty should be something like 25% of the calculated value of an army in coins?

ur teaching ur troops to run away
u should lose some prestige if u retreat

That doesn't even really make sense.

Wouldn't you think there would be a penalty for running away than a reward?

Could just be me.

[GoldenRico]

FYI you don't get any prestige from the units killed in the retreat =/

... ur alrdy paying coins for it...