Change something....

My suggestion: Change alliances in some way!!! This is a core part of your gaming experience for Haypi, without it your experience is not complete. I have had a feeling for a while that alliance were worse than what they used to be. I was confirmed that feeling today, alliances are not families any more, I don't know why. You have tochange something or else Haypi will not be as good as it was....

very vague there...

Yeah I know, I don't know what they should change just something to keep players interested because it seems they aren't as interested as they used to be

Not much point making a thread if you don't know what they should actually change.

this bit of the forum is for suggestions... and suggesting something should be changed but not stating what should be doesn't help lol

I think what is meant is that now you can hop in and out of alliances now.

Pre mine wars, this was never a real issues but alliances tend to have fake members to come in and spy on troop counts etc... Would be nice to have last alliances log for all members so you have background of who you are letting in.

this bit of the forum is for suggestions... and suggesting something should be changed but not stating what should be doesn't help lol

Doesn't have to be specific. Plus if I were to state the ideas I like I would just be copying other posts. I have already stated the ideas I like by replying to a thread, or creating one.

Trading within the alliance would be helpful even of there was a small charge I find most can't get their treasure and just quit playing...

I would agree that there should be some changes to alliances. Since alliance wars came out, alliances became more of a sub-game that had no real impact (other than costing resources) on the main game.

There are many many great suggestions on these forums regarding how to enhance the player-alliance experience however they've been passed over time and again.